Notes from the Middleground

Notes from the Middleground

Share this post

Notes from the Middleground
Notes from the Middleground
The Right’s Economic Populism Is Stillborn
Eyes on the Right

The Right’s Economic Populism Is Stillborn

The dream may never die, but reality should dispel it

Damon Linker's avatar
Damon Linker
Jan 13, 2023
∙ Paid
19

Share this post

Notes from the Middleground
Notes from the Middleground
The Right’s Economic Populism Is Stillborn
20
Share
US Speaker of the House Kevin McCarthy, Republican of California, holds a press conference in Statuary Hall at the US Capitol in Washington, DC, January 12, 2023. (Photo by SAUL LOEB/AFP via Getty Images)
Twitter avatar for @mattyglesias
Matthew Yglesias @mattyglesias
First GOP bill: Make it easier for business owners to cheat on their taxes. Second bill: Large tax increase on the bottom seventy percent of the income distribution to cut taxes for the rich.
Twitter avatar for @sarahnferris
Sarah Ferris @sarahnferris
New: Rep. Buddy Carter confirms to me that his Fair Tax Act will get its first-ever floor vote as part of speaker talks. Bill abolishes IRS, eliminates tax code, replacing income taxes with consumption tax - rolling back pieces of GOP tax law It was a demand of the 20 holdouts
11:53 AM ∙ Jan 11, 2023
1,096Likes255Retweets
Twitter avatar for @mattyglesias
Matthew Yglesias @mattyglesias
They also renamed the House Education & Labor Committee on the grounds on the grounds that the word “labor” is an offensive slur against America’s job creators.
Image
12:11 PM ∙ Jan 11, 2023
213Likes20Retweets

As I indicated at the top of my last post before Christmas, I will be writing just twice next week, for Wednesday and Friday.


The election of Donald Trump in 2016 created a serious problem for conservative intellectuals.

For decades, they had mostly been defending a lightly updated version of the “fusionism” first articulated in the early National Review by Frank Meyer. This ideological configuration advocated moral traditionalism on social issues and support for pro-business libertarianism when it came to taxes and regulations.

Eyes on the Right is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

Trump blew that up during the 2016 campaign by vowing to leave Social Security and Medicare alone and to replace ObamaCare with an alternative that would provide affordable health care for all Americans. Then came talk of turning the GOP into a workers party that would combine hostility to immigration and free trade with an industrial policy to revive American manufacturing.

This appeared to make Trump a populist, not just in his crowd-pleasing attacks on the media and the elites who ran both parties, but also in what he hoped to accomplish in office. Yet aside from a dozen or so populist-inflected “reformicons” at various think tanks and magazines during the Obama administration, there was little intellectual infrastructure on the right to support such an agenda. It had to be built from scratch.

That’s how we got American Affairs. And American Compass. And Compact. And a newly populist-nationalist First Things. And The Postliberal Order. The GOP had changed. It aspired to help ordinary Americans, not just to make cut taxes for multi-millionaire donors. Yes, it would focus much more aggressively on waging and winning the culture war in both old and new ways. But it would also support, reform, and expand, rather than aim to shred, the safety net that supported American families in bad times and gave them a leg up in good ones. That’s what it would mean to vote for the Republican Party in the 2020s.

Republican Messaging

Yet something strange happened during the Trump administration. While these journals and think tanks were founded and began churning out erudite essays and white papers about ways to accomplish these new worker-friendly goals, the GOP attempted to eliminate the Affordable Care Act without proposing any alternative. The effort was defeated by a single vote. If the late Sen. John McCain had gone the other way, millions would have lost insurance coverage. Meanwhile, the bill that did get passed—the only major legislative accomplishment of the entire four years Trump held the presidency—was a massive corporate tax cut.

And now the Republicans have retaken the House with a narrow majority under a Democratic president. What are they promising to do? Pretty much exactly what the House Republicans did during the last Democratic presidency: Hold hearings designed to turn trivialities into scandals that will embarrass the man in the White House while revving up the GOP base; threaten default on the national debt as way to force cuts to entitlements and defense spending; and pass messaging bills.

A messaging bill is a piece of legislation that has no realistic chance of becoming law but serves as a means of declaring what a party would pass if it held the other chamber of Congress and/or the White House. Such bills are useful for keeping ideologically aligned activists excited and donor money flowing into coffers ahead of the next election coming down the pike.

Matt Yglesias’ first tweet at the top of this post gives you a sense of what the first of these bills aim to accomplish. It would slash funding for the Internal Revenue Service, which will make it much more difficult to conduct audits of potential tax cheats. The second would replace the income tax with a consumption tax, which would effectively amount to a huge tax cut for the wealthy and tax hike for the poor. Oh, and as the second tweet notes, the House Republicans also renamed a committee because the word “labor” supposedly smacks of Marxism and would insult America’s entrepreneurial makers on behalf of the takers.

The right’s policy-oriented economic populism, it would seem, is stillborn.

What the Party Wants

Many on the left will be inclined to respond to this statement with something like, No shit, Sherlock.

Keep reading with a 7-day free trial

Subscribe to Notes from the Middleground to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Damon Linker
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share